Diners Club was my first big, ‘blue chip’ client after I had set up my sales consultancy. They had a problem with their take-one boxes. These are the simple frames filled with prepaid membership applications you see in places like hotel lobbies. In the USA, I was told, they provided 18% of membership; in the UK just about none. They had tried everything to succeed, even shipping over American ‘experts’. Still nothing. So the Board offered a contract to me based on my Rank Xerox success, without any termination clause and paying a fixed sum for each accepted new member.
I fiddled about with it, long lonely nights driving around London, placing boxes in different places and in different establishments. A few months passed. One or two applications came in, still just about nothing. The Diners Club Sales Director was getting fidgetty. He saw it as an insult anyway I was even there on his patch! He would just love to bring it to an end. Then suddenly I twigged it, where the boxes should be placed and who should be rewarded for keeping them there. The applications started coming in ones and twos. How could it be spread outside London?. I found a theme here too. Applications increased. The sums on the commission cheques started growing month by month. The Diners Club Sales Director complained I was excluding his team from the commissions. I brought them in too. They were delighted. New membership spurted ahead again The twos became tens, then twenties; the twenties forties, and so on. Money was pouring in. At the last count, we were generating 13% of new Diners Club membership.
As you see so many times in selling, success can make everything just look too easy. Maybe the new Diners Club Manging Director, who was seconded from NatWest Bank, hated the monthly ritual of paying me huge commission cheques, maybe more than he earned. Anyway, after a couple of years or so of the good life, Diners Club broke the contract. No conversations. They just broke it. Lawyers became involved. Injunctions followed. The contract staggered on until the court date was set: and there we were, battling it out in the High Courts of Justice.
Diners Club made a payment into Court. My side, led by the eminent QC, Mr Fox-Andrews, took the view Diners Club should pay more. They should pay to buy back the contract based on the future flow of funds. Professors at the London Business School became involved, putting a current value on the future flow of funds. The other side based their case on the damage done to me personally. The arguments swayed to and fro over 4 or 5 days. The judge began interrupting to say the case needed to be settled without further cost. Clearly he was favouring the other side’s argument (though I still can’t understand why!). We had to move to settle.
The screen set now moved next morning to the hallowed vestibule of the High Court, Mr Fox-Andrews, a tall man, bowed forward in thought and argument, back against and kicking his heels on the pillar behind him. I put to him that I wasn’t very happy with the turn of events. If we had to settle, we could at least argue to be added back payment of commissions re Northern Ireland, which we discoved Diners Club had withheld. Very reasonable he thought; and off he marched to speak to his opposite number.
He returned happy with his discussion; but the delay in the decision seeemed interminable. The pillar received a few more kicks. “What are they doing?” he asked. “Probably phoning Diners Club in America for a decision”, I answered, “and the Director who is being woken up there will not be very pleased.” We continued to wait. And wait. And wait. Finally the decision. Diners Club were to withdraw their offer. To put it bluntly, I was in the deepest of deep s***. “I can’t believe I am hearing this”, my Counsel said loudly. “I am going off now to tell them exactly what I think of them.” “Oh dear”, I thought. ” It can only get worse.”
God took my under his wing that day. Both QCs were so upset by the brazen Diners Club approach they marched off in tandem to Diners Club to tell them either to reinstate the offer or they were both off the case. Diners Club submitted. The offer was reinstated. After costs were paid, I put about half of the value of the original Diners Club offer into my bank account; but I had lived through an exciting time, the injuctions had kept the commissions flowing for more than an extra year; and interest rates were now blossoming to 15%, even 17%.
What is all this about? This is the money I rolled over into woodland. And, through one of these woodlands, the ancient roadway ran by. It was the dispute over my use of this ‘green lane’ in a vehicle that was to take me back to the High Court again.
For Part 2 of 3, visit whatisselling.net 31 August, 2013
No comments